Objection to the Wain Homes Development on Lynch Road
At November's Parish Council meeting the following comments were agreed:
Thorverton Parish Council Transport Report Ecology Report
Objection to Planning application 26/01201/MFUL
Over many years Thorverton Parish Council (TPC) has
tried to achieve affordable housing for parishioners and others with local
connections. Lynch Close, Court Barton Close and Leonard Square (all
between 6 and 20 homes) have been supported by the PC, although in the case of
the Leonard Square development Council felt that the provision of the
affordable housing in that scheme was not transparently allocated. From
that experience the PC set up a working group which grew into the Thorverton Community
Land Trust (TCLT) which, supported by MDDC, is bringing forward a scheme for 15
affordable homes (12 at social rents 3 at discounted sale) on Silver Street.
The location was selected after an extensive review of eleven possible sites
and consultation with parishioners and has widespread support.
The Local Plan policy S13 supports this level of
limited development in villages such as Thorverton. However, in 2024 the newly
elected government legislated that a shortfall in a planning authorities’ Five
Year Housing Land supply would trigger a ‘tilted balance’ in favour of housing
applications and that Local Plan Policies would carry little weight.
MDDC has a shortfall in meeting their national
targets and as a result two disproportionately large and speculative schemes
are being proposed for Thorverton. Both were presented by their promoters at
very well attended Parish Council Meetings. The overwhelming sentiment at those
meetings was opposition. Some residents have established a privately funded
group, Thorverton Community Action (TCA) to oppose the developments. TPC
undertook a survey with 139 responses of which 85% supported
the expenditure of reserves to take professional advice in its role as a
Statutory Consultee.
This is an unprecedented level of opposition from a
community that usually takes a pragmatic attitude to planning issues. As a
result TPC engaged a specialist transport consultant, Mr Alan James and a
company specialising in ecological issues, Elite Ecology. Both reports
are attached to this document and are referred to below.
Application 26/01201/MFUL.
The application proposes 66 houses off Lynch Rd,
reduced from the 92 that were subject to pre-app advice. The site for those 26
houses is identified as potential future development and is served by the
proposed road layout but is outside the red line of the application.
Parishioners are strongly opposed; as at 10th
November there have been 173 objector comments on the MDDC Planning Portal
opposing application 26/01201/MFUL .
The scale of the proposal, impact on traffic
through the village and the exaggerated claims of facilities and transport
connectivity are the most cited concerns, along with sewage and other
infrastructure issues.
Following the introduction of the latest National
Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) on 17th August this year the
previous provisions that would have been relied on by the applicants have been
replaced.
They now rely on NPPF 26 Policy S5j (1).
Be physically well-related to an existing
settlement (unless the nature of the development would make this inappropriate)
and be of a scale which can be accommodated taking into account the existing or
proposed availability of infrastructure.
Also relevant is NPPF 26 Policy TR3 1.a
Development proposals which could generate a
significant amount of movement, in the context of the area within which they
would be situated, should be in locations that are sustainable (or which can be
made so, taking into account planned improvements, including any provided for
as part of the development itself). This means the location should limit the
need to travel, particularly by private car, and offer a genuine choice of
transport modes for residents and users, unless the nature of the development
would make this impractical;
At its meeting on 11th Nov TPC resolved
to object to this application and urge MDDC to refuse it. TPC maintains
the application should be refused because:-
The proposed development is not sustainable:
The transport consultant Alan James’s report
(attached) concludes with this statement – “The TA makes some sweeping
assertions that the Thorverton housing development is in a sustainable location
and meets sustainable transport criteria. In reality, it is a fairly routine
housing scheme of mostly detached houses with lavish car parking provision,
aimed at people who will almost certainly commute by car to employment centres
several miles away, notably Exeter. It says little more than residents could
walk, cycle, or use public transport to access some facilities, without
providing any convincing argument or evidence that they would do so, set
against considerable evidence to the contrary.”
The suggested drainage plans are challenged by
Elite Ecology’s report:
We quote from page 35 of the attached report
(attached), commissioned by TPC:
“Overall, the review finds that the proposed
drainage strategy is potentially capable of
being developed into an acceptable solution, and
there is no basis at this stage for
concluding that the site is inherently incapable of
being satisfactorily drained.
However, a number of material matters remain
unresolved, including the attenuation storage discrepancy, the status of the
proposed outfall, groundwater-related design constraints, and the need for
improved source-control SuDS and clearer treatment of
existing and external flow pathways.
These matters are collectively significant enough
that the drainage proposals cannot
yet be regarded as sufficiently resolved to justify
withdrawal of the current technical
objection. This conclusion is consistent with the
present position of Devon County
Council as Lead Local Flood Authority. Accordingly,
Thorverton Parish Council is
advised to maintain its hydrology and surface-water
drainage objection to Planning
Application 26/01201/MFUL at this stage, pending
submission of the outstanding
technical information, satisfactory resolution of
the identified inconsistencies and
subsequent confirmation from the Lead Local Flood
Authority that an acceptable
drainage solution has been demonstrated.”
The proposed site is
not physically well related to the existing settlement:
It is on the west side at the furthest point from
the main access from the A396; TCLT considered and canvassed
opinion on 11 possible sites and after consultation with MDDC planning chose a
location on Silver St on the east of the settlement.
It represents an 18.9% increase in the area inside
the settlement line (ref Qualified Chartered Architect, Andrew Saunders)
The scale of development cannot be accommodated by
existing infrastructure:
Roads and pavements are completely inadequate and
cannot be improved. The main thoroughfare through the centre of the village is
Bullen St, which is only wide enough for one vehicle to pass at a time and, as
a result, there is frequent congestion. Of more importance there are no
pavements on the access route to the village from the site, Lynch Road.
Pedestrians have no choice but to share this busy road with all manner of
vehicles – cars, buses, HGV and tractors.
In addition Devon County Council as
Highway Authority has objected to the proposal on two grounds.
“1. The proposal is contrary to NPPF
(August 2026) policy F8(2)(b) due to the proposed
drainage solution adding surface water
from private land into a pipe that currently only drains ‘highway water’ into a
third party watercourse. The Highway Authority only holds responsibility for
draining water from existing public highways and cannot be relied upon to drain
other surface water from the development. As a result, the proposal does not
have maintenance arrangements in place to ensure an acceptable standard of
operation for the anticipated lifetime of the development.”
“2. The proposal is contrary to NPPF
(August 2026) policy TR6 (and also TR3; TR4 and
DP3(2)(d)) as the transport assessment
that supports the proposal does not adequately
assess the proposal (by its own
admission) because it does not reflect the transport vision for the development
and the transport strategy for the area in which it is located, and how these
are intended to be achieved (including, in the case of the travel plan,
identifying fallback options if initial measures do not deliver the expected
outcomes). Consequently, the development proposals have not been shown to be
acceptable having regard to the potential impacts and the other policies in the
Framework which are relevant (including TR3, TR4 and DP3(2)(d))”
There is no proposal to enlarge the overloaded
sewer and sewage works:
We quote a local resident, Mr Stephen Toogood, a
retired member of the Chartered Institute of Water and Environmental Management
Wastewater Technical Panel.
“In summary, I foresee that the proposed
development would increase the likelihood of pollution of the River Exe from
these sources: - increased likelihood of storm sewage overflows from the Bullen
Street SSO; - increased likelihood of storm sewage overflows from Thorverton
sewage treatment works; - discharge of untreated ammoniacal nitrogen; -
increased likelihood of breaching consent levels for both BOD and suspended
solids. 15. The application is at odds with Planning Policies S9, DM4, and P3.
16. As a result I would wish to see not only the prescribed assessments of
impact and mitigation, but also verifiable plans for capital investment in
sewerage and wastewater treatment before considering the proposed housing
development.”
In addition we also quote local resident Mrs Jean
Brown
“In 2025 Thorverton Sewage works
spilled untreated sewage into the River Exe on 14 occasions for a total of 54
hours and 8 minutes. The combined sewer overflow in Bullen Street was also
responsible for a spill into the local brook lasting for 1 hr and 35 minutes.”
The design of the development is incongruous to the
village:
We quote from Qualified Chartered Architect, Mr
Andrew Saunders:
“The two long elevation drawings that have been
offered, are clumsy, and lack any true architectural understanding of the
balance between continuity and contrast that go to create street scenes which
have an interesting yet coherent character, such as those that are prevalent in
Thorverton.
The use of appropriate building frontage widths and
the relationship between the footprint of neighbouring properties is also of
great importance, as is the use of local architectural language, in terms of
rooflines, and boundary treatments etc, which all help to create a distinct
"sense of place". However, if the quality of the materials used
in a palette of brick, render, tile and natural slate, is carefully selected,
and the detailing is of an accomplished standard, it could help to lend a
degree of local distinctiveness.
It is therefore to be regretted that a leading
house builder in the south west has demonstrated such little awareness of what
constitutes a suitable form of development for a prominent site on the edge of
one of Mid Devon's most historic and attractive villages. Instead, the
developers have trotted out the same formulaic solution that they apply to all
of their sites and have been doing so for in excess of 25 years. Thorverton
deserves an awful lot better than this.”
The application from Wain Homes is incomplete:
The application has numerous defects in relation to
its Transport Assessment, and merits rejection on these grounds alone. At a
very basic level, two Addendum documents to the TA have not been provided,
which the applicant accepted were essential to complete the TA. Traffic
surveys are still outstanding, which are required to enable a full traffic
impact assessment
The Historic Environment team’s objection:
“Given the unknown potential for survival and
significance of any below ground archaeological deposits associated with the
known prehistoric activity in this area and the absence of sufficient
archaeological information, the Historic Environment Team objects to this
application.”
It should be noted that evidence of an ancient
settlement was discovered in an archaeological dig ten years ago as part of
TPCs application for a new cemetery; this survey was approx 100 metres from the
Wain site.
The Ecology surveys are incomplete:
DCC commented that “a number of dwellings look
out onto the proposed dark corridors; clarification is required on the impact
that car headlights will have on the ecological functionality of the corridors
for bats and dormice. The lighting reports focus only on street lighting.
Clarification is required on the impacts on both external and internal light
spill from dwellings on the functionality of the dark corridors”.
In reaching these conclusions Councillors have been
guided by their own local experience, the views of residents, and is especially
grateful to Jean Brown, Andrew Saunders and Stephen Toogood for permission to
quote from their responses. The two reports from Alan James and Elite
Ecology are attached.
TPC would be pleased to attend a meeting with MDDC,
given notice, to discuss this application in more detail.
---------------------------------------------------------
Meetings: Council meetings are held in Thorverton Memorial
Hall on the second Tuesday of the month and usually start at 7:30pm. Meeting
agenda and minutes will be published, in the usual way, under the relevant tab at the top of this page and on the notice board in School Lane.
Devon County Council update: For the latest DCC news follow this link to the DCC website.
Mid Devon District Council update: For the latest MDDC news follow this link to the MDDC website.
Allotments: The Parish Council runs the allotments next to the garages at the end of Broadlands. If you would like to join the waiting list please contact the clerk for more information.